For years, I have been working with the wrong dog for obedience. Wyatt is so motivated to learn and so quick to learn that I worked with him for years and trained him to utility. However, despite many, many attempts (I stopped counting), we have never been able to qualify in AKC Open Obedience. He needs lots of double commands in the ring, especially for the recall, does not sit while heeling, and has trouble with the long sit. He does all these things perfectly at home and even right outside the ring. He does this even though he is an awesome rally dog (you can talk to your dog in rally) frequently scoring 98, 99, and 100 and placing in large classes full of traditional obedience breeds. The lack of verbal reinforcement and stimulation provided by agility seems to really hamper him in traditional obedience.
Patriot has been much slower to learn and not nearly as motivated to practice and especially retrieve. I started training him more seriously about a year ago. He has multiple issues in his first outing but I was amazed at his performance last week where he would have got a 193/200 and a second place had be not went down on the long sit. So I learned that confidence in the ring is even more important that being a quick learner, at least if you want to compete. I am excited to be working with Patriot more and competing again. We have been working daily on the long sit.